adidas Terrex AX4 GTX — $104.03
The most technically specified listing in the roundup. This is the in core black, grey three and mint ton, women's model HQ1051, made in Vietnam. Gore-Tex is named in the title, which is the detail that matters: a named membrane is a real waterproof liner, not a surface treatment. At just over $100 it is the most expensive shoe here, and it is still a fraction of the retail price on a current Terrex GTX.
- Gore-Tex membrane named in the listing, a genuine waterproof liner
- Full model number HQ1051 and colourway stated
- Trail-oriented build from adidas' outdoor line
- The women's sizing narrows your options, so verify your size early
- At $104.03 it is the priciest pick, so buy only if you need the membrane
This is the one to buy if your hiking involves mud, standing water or sustained rain and you are not willing to accept wet feet. Buy it if waterproofing is non-negotiable and you are shopping the women's size run.
REI Co-Op Swiftland MT BlueSky — $69.99
The come in men's size 8.5, undyed and lime, with the listing noting a $150 retail and that the original box is included. This is the single most interesting value in the roundup on paper, because a seventy-dollar discount against a stated retail with the box included is a textbook reseller playbook. What you are actually buying is an off-road-capable trail shoe with a mountain-leaning outsole at roughly half of the stated retail.
- Listing states a $150 retail for a $69.99 asking price
- Original box included, which helps with sizing confidence and resale
- Purchased from REI and described as guaranteed authentic
- Available only in men's 8.5 in this listing
- Undyed and lime colourway shows trail mud quickly
Because the box is included and the size is stated, this is one of the lowest-friction buys in the article. Buy it if you wear a men's 8.5 and want a mountain-style outsole with the original packaging.
Vans MTE Crestline Waterproof — $90.00
The is a high-top in solid brown, offered in a men's 5.5 and a women's 7. Vans MTE is their outdoor line and the Crestline is described specifically for hiking, with a lace-up closure and a high-top profile. The appeal is obvious: it is a fashion-forward high-top that will not look out of place in a town, and the waterproofing is a stated feature rather than something you are inferring.
- High-top shaft gives more ankle coverage than a trail runner
- Stated as waterproof for outdoor activities
- Neutral brown colour is the easiest to style in town
- Offered at an unusual split sizing, men's 5.5 and women's 7
- Not described with a named membrane, so ask whether it is a liner or a treatment
This is the pick for someone whose hiking is as much about looking the part as covering ground, and who wants one pair for both. Buy it if you want a high-top with a casual silhouette and you can confirm the membrane type with the seller.
Merrell Moab 2 Waterproof — $57.99
The deserve singling out, because Merrell is the strongest hiking-specialist brand in this roundup and the Moab 2 is its most popular hiking shoe platform. This listing is for a men's size 15 in brown and grey, described as hard to find, with a rugged Vibram-style outsole, breathable mesh panels and suede overlays. Size 15 is genuinely difficult to buy new, which is precisely why this listing is interesting rather than suspicious.
- Merrell is a dedicated hiking brand, not a general footwear label
- Vibram-style outsole described for grip
- Mesh panels and suede overlays combine breathability and durability
- Hard-to-find men's size 15, so availability will not last
- Only one size offered, and no women's equivalent in this listing
At $57.99 in a size that is nearly impossible to find new, this is the deal with the least obvious downside in the roundup. Buy it if you wear a large men's size and want a recognised hiking platform rather than a generic boot.
Timberland Aerocore Waterproof Hiker — $50.00
The is a black, rugged, all-terrain waterproof boot in a men's 13, from the Timberland 1978 Aerocore line, described with a gel sole and as travel-ready. Size 13 is another hard-to-find width, and the seller flags a slight cosmetic issue that is not detailed in the excerpt. At $50.00 for a full-height waterproof boot from a recognised brand, the price is the headline and the size is the real opportunity.
- Recognised brand at a sub-$60 price for a waterproof boot
- Men's size 13, a width that is hard to source new
- Gel sole and all-terrain positioning in the seller's description
- Unsold looks, so ask the seller to describe the flaw precisely
- Full-height boot is heavier than a trail runner for long days
The seller is upfront that there is a slight flaw, and at this price that is a reasonable trade for the size availability. Buy it if you wear a 13 and can live with a minor cosmetic mark.
Northwest Territory Waterproof Hiking Boots, Rae Model — $87.69
The , have a suede upper, textile lining, synthetic sole and a lace-up fastening. The construction description is honest and specific, and it is worth reading it carefully: a synthetic sole is the weakest link in this group, because synthetic outsoles wear faster and offer less grip on wet rock than the Vibram-style sole on the Merrell or the gel sole on the Timberland.
- Suede upper with a textile lining and lace-up fastening
- Synthetic sole, the main compromise in this listing
- Waterproof is stated, though no membrane is named
- Brand is less established than Merrell or Timberland
- At $87.69 it is close to the adidas price with less certainty behind it
Worth a look if the sizing works, but the synthetic sole and unnamed membrane make this a step down from the Merrell for technical terrain. Buy it if you walk maintained trails rather than anything steep, wet or loose.